ÿþ<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01 Transitional//EN"> <html> <head> <title>The Canada Society of Yi Jing (The Book of Changes)</title> <meta http-equiv="content-type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8" /> <meta name="keywords" content="Canada Society of Yi Jing, The Book of Changes, Yi Jing, I Ching, Yi" /> <meta name="robots" content="all" /> <meta name="author" content="Serena Deng" /> <meta name="description" content="Canada Society of Yi Jing - The Book of Changes" /> <link href="../includes/css.css" rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" /> <script type='text/javascript' src='../includes/javascript.js'></script> <script type='text/javascript' src='../includes/calendar.js'></script> </head> <body> <div id="main"> <div id="left"> <!-- Left side elements placed here --> <div id="logo"> <!-- Logo image placed here --> <!-- Logo must be at a fixed width of 150px --> <img src="../images/yjlogo.jpg" width="150" height="150" alt="The Canada Society of Yi Jing (The Book of Changes)" /> <img src="../images/space.gif" height="5"> </div> <div id="nav"> <!-- Navigation items placed here --> <!-- Main navigation items should be enclosed by <a> tags --> <!-- Subnavigation items should be in a list (<ul> tags), with each item separated by <a> and then <li> tags --> <!-- Maximum width of images here is 148px --> <div> <a href="index_en.htm">Home</a> <div id="nav01">&nbsp;</div> </div> <div onMouseOver="subNavOpen('nav02')" onMouseOut="subNavClose('nav02')"> <a href="javascript:subNavChange('nav02')"><img class="navarrow" src="../images/arrowd.gif" />About Yi Jing</a> <div id="nav02"><ul> <a href="whatis.htm"><li>What is Yi Jing</li></a> <a href="reducfallacy.htm"><li>Fallacy: A Divination book</li></a> <a href="unilaws.htm"><li>Laws Of the Universe</li></a> </ul></div> </div> <div onMouseOver="subNavOpen('nav03')" onMouseOut="subNavClose('nav03')"> <a href="javascript:subNavChange('nav03')"><img class="navarrow" src="../images/arrowd.gif" />Yijing, Science & Civilization</a> <div id="nav03"><ul> <a href="exampley&s.htm"><li>Yijing and Modern Science</li></a> <a href="exampley&cs.htm"><li>Yijing and Chinese Science</li></a> </ul></div> </div> <div onMouseOver="subNavOpen('nav04')" onMouseOut="subNavClose('nav04')"> <a href="javascript:subNavChange('nav04')"><img class="navarrow" src="../images/arrowd.gif" />The Study of Zhou Yi</a> <div id="nav04"><ul> <a href="handbook.htm"><li>Handbook</li></a> <a href="evidenceyi.htm"><li>New Evidences</li></a> <a href="evidencebased.htm"><li>Evidence-based Interpretation</li></a> <a href="classicalbook.htm"><li>Classical Books</li></a> <a href="bookreview.htm"><li>Book Review</li></a> </ul></div> </div> <div onMouseOver="subNavOpen('nav05')" onMouseOut="subNavClose('nav05')"> <a href="javascript:subNavChange('nav05')"><img class="navarrow" src="../images/arrowd.gif" />History of Yi Academy</a> <div id="nav05"><ul> <a href="profilehistory.htm"><li>Profile History</li></a> <a href="indeterminate.htm"><li>Origin of Indeterminate Analysis</li></a> </ul></div> </div> <div onMouseOver="subNavOpen('nav06')" onMouseOut="subNavClose('nav06')"> <a href="javascript:subNavChange('nav06')"><img class="navarrow" src="../images/arrowd.gif" />Prehistory of Yi Academy</a> <div id="nav06"><ul> <a href="fuxigua_e1.htm"><li>Archaeology of Fu Xi Yi</li></a> <a href="fuxigua_e2.htm"><li>Preshistorical Investigation</li></a> </ul></div> </div> <div onMouseOver="subNavOpen('nav07')" onMouseOut="subNavClose('nav07')"> <a href="javascript:subNavChange('nav07')"><img class="navarrow" src="../images/arrowd.gif" />Yi Divination and Sciences</a> <div id="nav07"><ul> <a href="yidivination_e1.htm"><li>Basic Differences</li></a> <a href="yidivination_e2.htm"><li>Science Basis</li></a> </ul></div> </div> <div onMouseOver="subNavOpen('nav08')" onMouseOut="subNavClose('nav08')"> <a href="javascript:subNavChange('nav08')"><img class="navarrow" src="../images/arrowd.gif" />Traditional Applications of Yijing</a> <div id="nav08"><ul> <a href="yimedicine.htm"><li>Yijing and Chinese Medicine</li></a> <a href="fengshuisci.htm"><li>Feng Shui and Sciences</li></a> <a href="fatecalculation.htm"><li>Fate Calculation and Sciences</li></a> </ul></div> </div> <div onMouseOver="subNavOpen('nav10')" onMouseOut="subNavClose('nav10')"> <a href="javascript:subNavChange('nav10')"><img class="navarrow" src="../images/arrowd.gif" />Members Area</a> <div id="nav10"><ul> <a href="society.htm"><li>Society Board</li></a> <a href="bylaws.htm"><li>Society Bylaws</li></a> <a href="news0205.htm"><li>Monthly Newsletter</li></a> <a href="memberappl.htm"><li>Membership Application</li></a> </ul></div> </div> <a href="links.htm">Links</a> <img src="../images/space.gif" height="5"> </div> <div id="splash"> <!-- Splash items placed here --> <!-- This section is optional; delete the splasharea div area to leave it blank --> <!-- Maximum width of images here is 138px --> <div id="splasharea"> <p>The Canada Society <br /> of Yi Jing <br />(The Book of Changes)<br /> 10939-38 Avenue<br /> Edmonton, AB<br /> Canada T6J 0K6</p> </div> </div> <div id="splashend"> <!-- Additional splash items may be placed here, but this section is fixed at 100 pixels in height; overflow material is hidden --> <!-- Maximum width of images here is 140px --> <p>&nbsp;</p> </div> </div> <div id="content"> <!-- Main page content is placed here --> <!-- h1, h2, p, a, img, ul tags styled --> <!-- Maximum width of images here is 430px --> <h1>Reduction to Absurdity of the Fallacy: "Yijing is Originally a Divination Book" </h1> <p>by Deng Honghai</p> <p> Through thoroughly examining the ancient literatures regarding Yijing, this book approach to the entire process of origin and development of the statement that Yijing is originally a divination book. The truth of the process is: in the 8 thousand-year history of Yi Academy, the statement has prevailed only for a limited period of about 2 thousands of years from Ban Gu (32-92), a scholar in the Eastern Han Dynasty, who first assumed this statement, to today. Even in the 2 thousand-year period, not everybody but only the following groups of people have been its believers and promoters since the Eastern Han Dynasty: </p> <p> <ol> <li><p>The pro-Confucian followers who have tried to support and promote Confucianism s monopolization in the academic world by spreading Ban Gu s assumption that  Yijing is originally a book of divination ;</p></li> <li><p>Scholars who have believed in the new Confucian leader Zhu Xi s (1130-1200) duet that  Yijing is originally a book of divination, but contains the laws of the nature . This has been the so-called two-point doctrine that has made Ban Gu s assumption become an official definition of  divination book . </p></li> <li><p>Skepticists who use the definition of  divination book to completely negate Yijing.</p></li> <li><p>Traditional practitioners of wits, such as fortune-teller, Feng Shui masters, quack doctors, itinerant entertainers, etc., who abuse Yijing as a book of divination to swindle others for money in the name of Yijing.</p></li> </ol> </p> <p> This book lists the systematical evidences from archaeological findings in matching with records in ancient literatures to reduce to absurdity of the fallacy  Yijing is originally a divination book . Meanwhile, the evidences restore the truth of Yijing in the first 6 thousands of years, which were divided into two eras: prehistorical and historical. In prehistorical era, Yi academy was a practical knowledge system for people to realize the universe and develop science and technology for maintaining and improving their livelihood. In the historical era, Yi academy was increasingly deified to be the highest Holy Classic full of the Heavenly, Earth and Human laws to direct everything, including divination and other forms of decision making, in national affairs and people s livelihood. </p> <p>&nbsp;</p> </div> <div id="right"> <!-- Right side elements placed here --> <div id="rightnav"> <table> <th><a href="../Yi_Jing_EN/reducfallacy.htm">Eng</a></th> <th><a href="../Yi_Jing_TC/reducfallacy_bg5.htm">A~SO</a></th> <th><a href="../Yi_Jing_SC/reducfallacy_GB.htm">€{SO</a></th> </table> </div> <div id="rightwhite"> <!-- Whitespace, ignore --> <div id="cornertl"> <!-- Top left page corner decoration; do not modify --> <img src="../images/cornertl.gif" /> </div> <!-- Top right page corner decoration; do not modify --> <div id="cornertr"> <img src="../images/cornertr.gif" /> </div> </div> <div id="rightmain"> <div id="righttext"> <!-- Right blurb items, such as ads or related items, here --> <!-- Maximum width of images is 130px --> <h1>Your inputs are always welcome!</h1> <p> You are welcome to input your comments, suggestions, supports and donations. </p> <p> There is a bank account of our society for raising funds. </p> <p> All proceeds will be used to fund publishing the books mentioned above, developing international cooperation on the theme, promoting Universe Yi research and education. </p> <p> You can contact us by mail via our mailing address on the left side of the page or email at <a href="javascript:antiSpam('jvs','shaw.ca')">jvs@shaw.ca</a>. </p> </div> <p><CENTER> <SCRIPT LANGUAGE="JavaScript"> getBgn(); </SCRIPT> </CENTER></P> </div> <div id="rightend"> <!-- Additional blurb area; items may be placed here but this section is fixed at 100 pixels in height; overflow material is hidden --> <!-- Maximum width of images is 140px --> <p>&nbsp;</p> </div> </div> <div id="footer"> <!-- Page copyright information; do not modify --> <!-- Bottom left page corner decoration; do not modify --> <div id="cornerbl"> <img src="../images/cornerbl.gif" /> </div> <div> <p id="foottext"> &copy; 2004 The Canada Society of Yi Jing (The Book of Changes). Website designed by <a href="javascript:antiSpam('serenadeng','fmgirl.com')">Serena Deng</a>. </p> </div> <!-- Bottom right page corner decoration; do not modify --> <div id="cornerbr"> <img src="../images/cornerbr.gif" /> </div> </div> </div> </body> </html>